SWNZ Forums

He makes some great points very eloquently and with humour, so they stick. While it was funny in most of his other reviews, I thought he went a bit far and over indulged in the serial killer stuff in his AOTC analysis, ironically falling into some of the same pits he suggests Lucas stumbled into with the prequels, but if you can make it through that stuff the rest is all pretty good. If you like Trek I would recommend his Star Trek TNG movie reviews as well.

Reverend Strone wrote:He makes some great points very eloquently and with humour, so they stick. While it was funny in most of his other reviews, I thought he went a bit far and over indulged in the serial killer stuff in his AOTC analysis, ironically falling into some of the same pits he suggests Lucas stumbled into with the prequels, but if you can make it through that stuff the rest is all pretty good. If you like Trek I would recommend his Star Trek TNG movie reviews as well.

cheers rev! Yes I will check those out

Be prewarned, he liked the TNG movies about as much as he liked the SW prequels! But, he does raise some really good reasons for why they fall short in his opinion, and I find I must agree with most of his points. The dude is clearly a TNG series fan and knows his Trek.

Reverend Strone wrote:Be prewarned, he liked the TNG movies about as much as he liked the SW prequels! But, he does raise some really good reasons for why they fall short in his opinion, and I find I must agree with most of his points. The dude is clearly a TNG series fan and knows his Trek.

Well that's the thing with him isn't it? It's not that he's some super critic looking in on the films and comparing them to other work he's got quite an indepth knowledge there. The dude clearly cares about the films.....